Choosing the Right Tax Structure: SCorp vs. Schedule C – A Comprehensive Guide

As a business owner, selecting the appropriate tax structure is a critical decision that can significantly impact your tax liability and overall financial well-being. Two common options are the S Corporation (SCorp) and Schedule C (Sole Proprietorship). In this blog article, we will delve into the benefits of each option, explore the deadlines for filing an SCorp election, and discuss the 3-year 75-day rule for late election relief while addressing potential failure-to-file penalties. Remember, making the right choice can lead to substantial tax savings, and seeking professional advice, such as from Hopkins CPA Firm, can help you navigate the complexities.

The Benefits of an SCorp vs. Schedule C

Liability Protection: One of the most significant advantages of forming an SCorp is the personal liability protection it provides to its shareholders. Business debts and legal liabilities are generally limited to the company, shielding individual shareholders from personal risk. In contrast, Schedule C business owners have unlimited personal liability for business debts, exposing their personal assets to potential risks.

  1. Tax Savings: SCorps offer potential tax advantages compared to Schedule C businesses. While both structures pass-through business income to the owners’ personal tax returns, SCorps may allow for more opportunities to reduce self-employment taxes. SCorp shareholders can receive a portion of their income as salary and the rest as distributions, potentially lowering the overall tax burden.
  2. Credibility and Perpetuity: An SCorp is a recognized legal entity, which can enhance a company’s credibility in the eyes of customers, suppliers, and investors. Additionally, SCorps have continuity beyond the owner’s life, making it easier to transfer ownership or secure funding for growth.
  3. Retirement Benefits: SCorp owners can establish retirement savings plans (e.g., 401(k)s) that offer higher contribution limits than those available to Schedule C businesses, providing an opportunity for substantial retirement savings.
  4. Investor Attraction: SCorps can issue different classes of stock, making it easier to attract investors and raise capital for expansion.


SCorp Election Deadlines for the Current Year

To elect SCorp status for the current tax year, the following deadlines must be met:

  • File Form 2553: To elect SCorp status for the current tax year, businesses must file Form 2553 with the IRS. Generally, this form must be filed no later than the 15th day of the third month of the tax year in which the election is intended to take effect. For calendar year entities, the deadline is March 15th.
  • Late Election: If a business misses the initial deadline, they may still qualify for late election relief. The 3-year 75-day rule allows businesses to request relief by filing Form 2553 within 3 years and 75 days from the start of the tax year the election was intended to take effect.


The 3-Year 75-Day Rule and Potential Failure-to-File Penalty

Late SCorp elections can result in severe consequences if not processed properly, including losing the tax benefits of the election. The 3-year 75-day rule is crucial in this context, as it provides a window for businesses to correct their oversight.

However, businesses should be aware of the potential failure-to-file penalty, which can amount to $210 per month (subject to change annually) for each shareholder, up to a maximum of 12 months. Despite this penalty, the potential tax savings from an SCorp election can far outweigh the failure-to-file penalty in appropriate circumstances.

Mitigating the Penalty: In certain situations, businesses can mitigate the failure-to-file penalty by demonstrating reasonable cause for the late election. Consulting with a tax professional, like those at Hopkins CPA Firm, can help navigate the process and present a strong case to the IRS.


Choosing between an SCorp and Schedule C requires careful consideration of the specific needs and goals of your business. Each structure offers unique benefits and considerations related to liability protection, tax savings, retirement benefits, and investor attraction. Understanding the deadlines for filing an SCorp election is crucial, and the 3-year 75-day rule can provide late election relief in some cases. Although a failure-to-file penalty may apply, the potential tax savings make it essential to explore all available options with a qualified tax professional. For personalized guidance and support, consider reaching out to Hopkins CPA Firm, where our team of experts can help you make the best decision for your business’s financial success.

Table of Contents


Joe Hopkins

Joe has 25+ years as a Certified Public Accountant licensed in the State of Texas and solving IRS problems. Current member with the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), Texas Society of CPA’s (TSCPA), National Society of Accountants (NSA), Bachelor’s degree in accounting (BBA), Master’s degree in Business Administration (MBA) at Texas A&M Corpus Christi. Experience in a variety of industries as Controller, CFO and tax resolution issues for both business and personal tax cases.